| Name | Accomplishment | Year |
| TJ Wright | ALL-FCIAC 1st Team | 2025 |
| TJ Wright | ALL-FCIAC 1st Team | 2024 |
| Will Syndor | ALL-FCIAC 1st Team | 2022 |
| Jason James | ALL-FCIAC 1st Team | 2021 |
| Paul Fabbri | ALL-FCIAC 1st Team | 2020 |
| Steve Paolini | ALL-FCIAC 1st Team | 2019 |
| Quincy McKnight | ALL-FCIAC 1st Team | 2013 |
| Timajh Parker | ALL-FCIAC 1st Team | 2012 |
| Timajh Parker | ALL-FCIAC 1st Team | 2011 |
| Greg Langston | ALL-FCIAC 1st Team | 2010 |
| Greg Langston | ALL-FCIAC 1st Team | 2009 |
| Nick Gerrity | ALL-FCIAC 1st Team | 2008 |
| Demetrius Jackson | ALL-FCIAC 1st Team | 2006 |
| Demetrius Jackson | ALL-FCIAC 1st Team | 2005 |
| Mitchell Gaines | ALL-FCIAC 1st Team | 2003 |
| Jared Pierce | ALL-FCIAC 1st Team | 2001 |
| Jared Pierce | ALL-FCIAC 1st Team | 2000 |
| Mike Vukamanovich | ALL-FCIAC 1st Team | 2000 |
| Rob Benedetto | ALL-FCIAC 1st Team | 1999 |
| TJ McKenzie | ALL-FCIAC 1st Team | 1997 |
| Name | Accomplishment | Year |
| TJ Wright | ALL-FCIAC 2nd Team | 2023 |
| Tommy Shannon | ALL-FCIAC 2nd Team | 2021 |
| Omar Telfer | ALL-FCIAC 2nd Team | 2017 |
| Omar Telfer | ALL-FCIAC 2nd Team | 2016 |
| Jonny Dzurenda | ALL-FCIAC 2nd Team | 2014 |
| Oscar Assie | ALL-FCIAC 2nd Team | 2011 |
| Taylor Petrucelli | ALL-FCIAC 2nd Team | 2007 |
| Marquis Reddick | ALL-FCIAC 2nd Team | 2006 |
| Jon Pierce | ALL-FCIAC 2nd Team | 2000 |
| Todd Klumkowski | ALL-FCIAC 2nd Team | 1999 |
| Name | Accomplishment | Year |
| Raheem Murray | ALL-FCIAC 3rd Team | 2023 |
| Dashawn Hall | ALL-FCIAC 3rd Team | 2022 |
| Gavin Greene | ALL-FCIAC 3rd Team | 2018 |
| Name | Accomplishment | Year |
| Jonny Dzurenda | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 2013 |
| Patrick Hopkins | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 2012 |
| Quincy McKnight | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 2012 |
| Oscar Assie | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 2010 |
| Oscar Assie | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 2009 |
| Kyle Walker | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 2009 |
| Greg Langston | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 2008 |
| Rob Harrigan | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 2008 |
| Rob Harrigan | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 2007 |
| Joey Desantis | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 2005 |
| Ryan O’Connor | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 2003 |
| Mitchell Gaines | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 2002 |
| Mark Gaines | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 2002 |
| Paul Sabo | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 2002 |
| Mark Gaines | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 2001 |
| Mike Vukamanovich | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 1999 |
| Larry Jackson | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 1998 |
| Rob Benedetto | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 1998 |
| Jim Driggs | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 1997 |
| Vernon Thompson | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 1997 |
| Tim Owens | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 1996 |
| TJ McKenzie | ALL-FCIAC EAST | 1996 |